Nurse Rogers is dentist Dr. Schwartz's assistant and receptionist. When the gang comes by to ask the dentist to have all their teeth pulled to get money from the tooth fairy to buy baseball equipment, she collaborates with him to scare the kids by bringing nasty looking tools into his office. While Dr. Schwartz is occupying the boys, she orders the baseball equipment, two balls and two gloves, which are there when the boys are ready to leave. The gift is attributed to the tooth fairy, and the gang promises to let their teeth come out naturally.
Miss Rogers was played by Marjorie Townsend.